The Modern Finance Playbook is a newsletter for today's finance professionals brought to you by Paul Barnhurst and Ron Monteiro.
Share
Modern Finance Playbook: Same Numbers, Different Conversation
Published 8 days ago • 6 min read
Inspirational Quote
“The most important thing in communication is hearing what isn’t said.”
- Peter Drucker
Brain Teaser of the Week
See the solution at the end of the email
Three Finance colleagues go out for lunch. The bill comes to $30, so each person contributes $10.
The waiter realizes the bill should have been $25 and returns $5.
The colleagues each take back $1, and they give the remaining $2 to the waiter as a tip.
So each person has now paid $9, for a total of $27.
The waiter has the $2 tip.
$27 + $2 = $29. Where did the missing dollar go?
Stay Out of Excel Hell
I’m thinking about changing the Excel Hell section. As more and more people say AI is the most important technical skill to learn, not Excel, I wanted to ask you what you would like to see. Tell me what you’d find most useful.
What do you want to see in the Excel Hell section?
Your feedback will be incredibly valuable as we look to keep the newsletter as relevant as possible.
Opportunities
I have two free live webinars coming up with Ramp, and I'd love for you to join me for either one or both if you can.
Data Visualization + Microsoft Excel: Top 10 Tips for More Compelling Charts
Data Storytelling is fundamental to FP&A, and it requires data, visuals, and narrative. Visuals are a key part of the story, and I'll share my top 10 tips for building stronger data visualizations, no matter what tool you use.
You'll learn how to:
· Apply core visualization principles so your message lands
· Choose the right chart for different data and scenarios
· Use tables, NA(), and Dynamic Arrays to enhance your charts
· See a brief demo of Excel's new interactive HTML dashboard
Budgeting AI usage is becoming a major concern for every company, especially after we saw companies like Uber use the full year's budget in 4 months. AI spend moves with usage and model choice, and at many companies, no one owns how AI gets used or what it costs. That gives finance an opening to lead.
We will cover:
What drives token costs and how you should think about budgeting them
Why experimentation belongs in the AI budget as a planned cost of learning
How finance can help lead the way when it comes to AI and AI cost management
Many of the best CFOs I know have spent time outside of finance. CFOs are being asked to do more than ever, and many are being asked to act as COOs. If you get the chance to work outside of finance, take it.
I've toyed with going back to full-time FP&A. If I did, I guarantee I'd be better at it than I was 5 years ago when I left to start my own business.
"I would not be in a CFO seat today had it not been for 6 years outside of finance. You learn so much about every other part of the business when you're outside finance, but you never lose the accounting or financial foundation."
Several guests on FP&A Unlocked have made similar points:
"Ambitious FP&A professionals should leave FP&A for some period of their career and go work in the other areas. If you really want to go and become a CFO, it's like go work in sales operations for a year or two and understand what they're going through." Alok Ajmera, CEO, Prophix
"I consider myself an unusual finance person because I approach finance from an operations perspective, always asking, 'What does this mean for the business?'" Zach Rial
"Let's ship somebody over into another function where they can learn more of the business and then bring them back." Eric Alexander, former CFO, Happy State Bank
If someone offers you a stint in operations, sales, or HR, my advice say yes. You'll bring more back to finance than you left with if you come back to finance, and if not, that is ok the business needs people who understand the financials.
Business Partner's Corner
Great Business Partners Know How to Communicate
Why one size fits one is the secret to stronger relationships.
Early in my career, I learned a valuable lesson about communication. And it wasn't exactly my finest leadership moment!
I was a new manager at Kraft Canada, having a team meeting around a table in the atrium of our beautiful office. During the meeting, I started debating an issue with one of my team members. I thought we were having a healthy discussion.
Apparently, she didn't see it quite the same way.
In the middle of our discussion, she got up and walked away!
I was stunned. What just happened?
I later realized that while I was comfortable debating a contentious issue openly, she preferred to have those conversations privately, especially with her manager.
The problem wasn't necessarily what I was communicating.
It was how, when and where I was communicating it.
That experience taught me a lesson that has stayed with me throughout my career.
One Size Fits One
We've all heard "one size fits all." When it comes to communication, I prefer a different philosophy.
One size fit ONE.
Some people love details. Others want the big picture. Some enjoy a spirited debate. Others prefer time to reflect.
Some want a 10-page report. Others want three bullet points and a recommendation!
As Finance professionals, we sometimes communicate the way WE prefer rather than considering our audience.
With a CFO, I might focus on financial implications, risks, and recommendations. With an Operations leader, I might focus on operational drivers and actions.
Same information. Different conversation.
The goal isn't to change your message. It's to change how you deliver it.
The Power of Mirroring
Another powerful technique is mirroring. Legendary personal development guru Tony Robbins often talks about this skill.
Skilled communicators subtly adapt to another person's style, helping create a sense of comfort and connection.
Here are four ways to practice:
Pace: If someone speaks slowly and thoughtfully, slow down.
Energy: Match some of the enthusiasm of an animated communicator.
Language: Use terminology that resonates with your audience.
Detail: Some want the executive summary. Others want to dig into the numbers.
Mirroring isn't about mimicking someone. It's about helping them feel comfortable and understood.
And don't forget body language! I've become much more conscious of watching facial expressions, posture, and engagement.
Don't just focus on delivering your message. Pay attention to how it's being received.
From Finance Expert to Trusted Business Partner
Technical expertise matters, but it alone doesn't build trust.
Great Finance Business Partners know when to challenge and when to listen. When to provide detail and when to simplify. When to push back and when to have a private conversation.
They understand that influencing someone starts with understanding them.
Putting It into Practice
In your next conversation, consider three things:
Know your audience: What matters to them and how do they prefer to communicate?
Practice mirroring: Adjust your pace, energy, and language.
Read the room: Watch for signs of engagement or discomfort and adjust accordingly.
Looking back, I'm grateful for that uncomfortable moment in the atrium. It reminded me that good intentions don't always translate into effective communication and I did apologize to my team member and changed my approach going forward.
The best communicators aren't necessarily the best speakers. They're the ones who make others feel heard, understood, and respected.
Joke of the Day
Boss: How good are you with spreadsheets?
Me: I Excel at it.
Boss: Did you just make a Microsoft Office pun?
Me: Word
Brain Teaser Answer
There is no missing dollar! The trick is in the math.
The $27 already includes the $25 lunch plus the $2 tip. Adding the tip again counts it twice.
The correct calculation is:
$25 (lunch) + $2 (tip) + $3 (returned) = $30.
The lesson? Even when the numbers are correct, how you present them can lead to the wrong conclusion. Sound familiar, Finance professionals.
This Week's Sponsor Inspirational Quote “Clear is Kind.” Brene Brown Brain Teaser of the Week See the solution at the end of the email Three people need to cross a river at night. They have one small boat that can carry a maximum of two people at a time. Alex can row across in 1 minute. Blake takes 2 minutes. Charlie takes 5 minutes. When two people cross together, they travel at the speed of the slower person. The boat cannot cross without someone rowing it back. What is the minimum time...
Hey Reader, "Your analysis was brilliant, but your presentation lacked." I will never forget my boss's words; they taught me the value of the last mile of analytics. I gave a presentation to my CFO that was a disaster, and it was because I did a poor job of presenting the solid analysis I had done. The last mile of analytics is the key to influencing the business, and a few bad data visualizations can often undo the whole presentation. On Wednesday, November 18, I'm running a free live...
Inspirational Quote “Effective Communication begins and ends with communication.” - Mike Krzyzewski Brain Teaser of the Week See the solution at the end of the email 🧠 A company increases its selling price by 20%, but as a result, sales volume drops by 20%. Assuming all other factors remain unchanged, what happens to total revenue? A) Revenue stays the same B) Revenue increases by 4% C) Revenue decreases by 4% D) Revenue decreases by 20% Upcoming AI Opportunities Learning AI is no longer...